Duncan is the winner! In order to be as scientific as possible, and to keep my head out of the outcome I did the drawing this way: First I wrote numbers from 1 to 16 each on a separate 16th of an 8.5x11 sheet of paper. Then I threw them up in the air and hoped that Miss-T, our puppy would grab one. She was not interested. So I decided on my original plan. Discarded all the face down numbers and did it again. After a while there were only 4 sheets left! So, with one more toss, only one number remained face up.... I took that number, and counted down from the top of the emails until I got to that number. Based on the order emails received. That name was Duncan! Thanks to all who entered :) PeterZ I sent it out today to Duncan. Sorry about the repost, but it looks like all the email does not go through. :( and some said that they did not receive it.